"I may not have gone where I intended to go, but I believe I have ended up where I needed to be." - Douglas Adams.
In 1991, I moved to Eugene to attend the University of Oregon. At the time, all I knew about Eugene and UO was that it was the pot-smoking, tie-dye wearing, hippie Mothership. Notably, that is the impression enjoyed by virtually everybody who purports to know anything about Eugene but doesn't live there.
During my time at UO, I worked as an editorial page editor and columnist for the student newspaper, the Oregon Daily Emerald. Much of what I wrote was, in my opinion, basically common sense. I didn't have a particularly strong Pavlovian attraction to any partisan ideology, although I had always been a registered republican.
While there, I discovered some fascinating things about perceptions and human nature. For starters, I can't make anybody happy. I received equal response to my editorials and columns from both liberal and conservative readers, and within that response was myself equally labeled a liberal and a conservative. During the 1992 presidential election season, I wrote an editorial critical of Democratic Senate candidate Les Aucoin (can't recall why), and immediately we were deluged with calls and letters wondering why we didn't simply endorse his Republican opponent. Democratic student leaders came to our office - how could we do this? (In fact, we ultimately endorsed AuCoin, as I recall).
Later, I wrote an editorial critical of Bill Clinton's visit to UO, noting that his campaign squandered an opportunity to talk to actual voters when it instead bused in thousands of school children who couldn't vote (and didn't care). At the time, Clinton was not certain to win, and every vote counted. Immediately, we were blasted for our hidden bias, and why didn't we just come out and support George H. W. Bush. (Again, we ultimately endorsed Bill Clinton).
What this told me was that partisans can't, or won't, listen to criticism of their candidates. It doesn't matter what the criticism is, whether it's directed at the candidate, a position, or in at least in one case, the decision to exclude thousands of voters from a rally while trying to garner those excluded-voters' votes. From this, I concluded that partisans are, by and large, unthinking and generally none-to-bright. (Sixteen years later, my opinion has been, I believe, validated).
However, while in the heart of the proverbial beast at UO, I discovered that the loud, liberal voice that was generally attributed to Eugene, was in fact limited to the UO and its immediate surroundings. Go a mile in any direction, and the political winds shifted dramatically to the right. (Maybe "dramatically" is too strong a term unless understood relative to the left-blowing Santa Ana-like winds on campus). However, those people outside of the campus are not remotely as loud as those near/on campus. Truly, a vocal minority conveyed the false impression that the entire community shared a view.
I go through this lengthy preamble to set up the topic here - the new vocal minority of the right. Subsequent to the 2000 election, there has been a belief that right-wing, conservative ideology is the majority ideology in the United States. That belief is based on the election and reelection of George W. Bush, and has been fueled by right-wing talk radio (coupled with the near abject failure of left-wing talk radio - see "Air America.").
The belief is misguided but, as I have explained above, it is also invulnerable to honest consideration and evaluation by right-wing partisans. They cannot, or will not, engage in rational evaluation of their positions.
Nonetheless, it cannot escape observation that Bush did not win the presidency by a landslide (if he won it at all). At a minimum, he lost the popular vote. That, coupled with an embarrassing and aimless campaign by Algore, resulted in Bush stumbling into a victory. In 2004, John Kerry also ran a ridiculous and aimless campaign that, again coupled with an aggressive and fear-mongering Rovian attack, again allowed Bush to literally squeak by and win reelection. The idea that Bush won because he represents a majority of Americans and their values is laughable, and simply counter to reality.
Worse, the rise of right-wing talk radio has enhanced that bogus opinion. Right-wingers listen to right-wing radio and call in to right-wing radio for one simple reason - they have the time. Either they're unemployed, retired, or have lots of down time at work. A lot of these people are simply mad at the government, believe their situation is the result of or worsened by government action, and suffer from delusions of government designs on their guns, on their God, or on their childrens' sexuality. It is probably unfair to label these people with generalizations, but such broad-stroke attacks seem to be the only thing they understand. Thus, I would label them as older, less educated, less informed, less literate, lower income. Basically, the poor and stupid. (Note: not all poor people are stupid, and not all stupid people are poor).
Meanwhile, left-wing radio is far less successful. I ascribe a handful of reasons to this. First, the left-wing is already the master of alternative media, leaving little appetite for mainstream media. Second, those folks who tend to lean left but are far from partisan have jobs that do not leave time for listening and/or calling into talk radio. Also, left-leaning people tend to socialize with other left-leaning people, and so they believe everybody already thinks like they do. (It is noteworthy that, in my observations, left-wing people tend to be far less tolerant of the company of right-wingers, whereas right-wingers will gladly socialize with left-wingers and not feel the need to preach. That tolerance, however, does not spill over into the voting booth or policy positions).
Nonetheless, it is this misguided perception of majority that is causing many right-wingers to come unglued at the prospect of a Democratic victory this fall. They truly cannot understand what is happening, and they are stunned that the talk-show crazies (i.e. Sean Hannity, Michael Savage, Glenn Beck) are not having more of an impact. It is beyond their abilities to realize that those talk shows are focused on narrowly-targeted hyper-partisans and that the larger public neither listens nor cares.
What has changed as of late is that these crazies have moved from calling radio shows to attending John McCain rallies. What is surprising is not the level of hate and insanity, but that McCain is dumb enough to hand microphones to these people. And although this is not where I intended to go, where I have ended up is here - John McCain continues to exercise not just questionable, but incredibly poor judgment.
(Thanks Dean, for inspiring me to waste part of my day writing this).
Monday, October 13, 2008
Friday, October 10, 2008
Politico.com Errs With Inflammatory Headline (Updated)
In reporting on a John McCain rally in Minnesota, Politico.com used the following headline: "Crowd boos after McCain says Obama not 'an Arab.'"
The story reports the crowd booing after various attempts by McCain to quell the rage building at the rally. However, in regard to the "Arab" comment, the story does not indicate any boos.
The specific exchange went like this:
The editors at Politico.com need to do a better job of ensuring their headlines fairly reflect the content of their stories. It's little things like this that cause people to distrust political websites and the media generally.
UPDATE: Politico.com has changed the headline, which now reads: "McCain: Obama not an Arab, crowd boos." Technically accurate, albeit inartful.
The story reports the crowd booing after various attempts by McCain to quell the rage building at the rally. However, in regard to the "Arab" comment, the story does not indicate any boos.
The specific exchange went like this:
Crazy Old Lady: "I can't trust Obama. I have read about him and he's not, he's no,t uh, he's an Arab. He's not ..."
And with that, the audience broke into applause. You can see the exchange here:
McCain: "No Ma'am. He's a decent family man [and] citizen that I just happen to have disagreements with on fundamental issues and that's what this campaign's all about. He's not [an Arab]."
The editors at Politico.com need to do a better job of ensuring their headlines fairly reflect the content of their stories. It's little things like this that cause people to distrust political websites and the media generally.
UPDATE: Politico.com has changed the headline, which now reads: "McCain: Obama not an Arab, crowd boos." Technically accurate, albeit inartful.
Labels:
arab terrorist,
McCain,
minnesota,
obama,
politico.com
Bad Movie Done In By Vast Left-Wing Theater Conspiracy
This past weekend two movies opened that, I thought, might provide an early indicator of the public split between liberal and conservative. In particular, I thought it would shed a light on the idea, so often asserted on right-wing talk radio, that "conservatives" are the majority in this country.
Two movies - David Zucker's "An American Carol" and Bill Maher's "Religulous" undertake to preach to their respective choirs about the inherent insanity of the other choir. In short, "An American Carol" is an effort to mock left-wing filmmaker Michael Moore and his (real or imagined) disdain for America, while "Religulous" is an attempt to mock organized religion and its adherents.
I'm not particularly a fan of either movie (based on style, not substance - I haven't seen either). But I don't like movies that have as an agenda the mockery of people for their beliefs. Just because I might disagree with someone's beliefs doesn't give me the right to mock them. Challenge and question them, yes. But outright mockery? I just think that's in poor taste. But to each his own.
That said, there are a lot of people who will find these movies funny and entertaining, for no other reason than each respective movie supports and reflects the world views of those who like each movie. And with that in mind, I figure that you can identify the general compass of the nation by which movie does better at the box office.
Fortunately, both movies opened the same weekend, so neither movie could attribute a poor performance to an event that took place on its opening weekend that did not take place on the opening weekend of the other movie.
Reviews were not mixed. "Religulous" gained a 68% Fresh Rating at RottenTomatoes. Erstwhile, "An American Carol" received only a 13% Fresh Rating. Translated to normal English - reviewers liked "Religulous" and did not like "An American Carol." In fact, in my observations, I don't think I have seen more than a couple movies ever rate worse than "An American Carol" on RottenTomatoes.
When the opening week box-office numbers came out, "An American Carol" opened at number 9, while "Religulous" opened at number 10. Gross numbers reflected "An American Carol" earned $4,354,000, while "Religulous" earned $4,202,216. (You can see the week's charts here in Variety. Be sure to look at the week ending Oct. 9, 2008).
On its face, it appeared that "An American Carol" won out, albeit by a slim margin. But that's not the whole picture. "An American Carol" opened on 1,639 screens, averaging $2,656 per screen. "Religulous" opened on only 502 screens, but averaged $8,371 per screen. Thus, on a per screen basis, "Religulous" won the week by an overwhelming margin. What that translates into is "Religulous" played to packed houses, while "An American Carol" played to roughly 25% filled seats.
Apparently, the abysmal per-screen showing of "An American Carol" has inspired tales of a vast theater conspiracy to skew the ticket sales. Stories abound that theaters took money for "An American Carol" and then printed out tickets for something else.
On NewsBusters, commentator Warner Todd Huston suggests that it "wouldn't surprise [him] if it turned out that certain people were trying to doom this film," in regard to the ticket sales issue. Huston's post also contains a link to the movie's website where people can report fraudulent ticket sales. As of this posting, no such link exists. Huston himself notes the absence of the link in a subsequent posting (wherein he also denies alleging the existence of a conspiracy - I'll let you interpret his above quote however you choose).
Notably, few on the right want to acknowledge that, just maybe, "An American Carol" isn't very good, got poor reviews, and nobody went to see it.
Two movies - David Zucker's "An American Carol" and Bill Maher's "Religulous" undertake to preach to their respective choirs about the inherent insanity of the other choir. In short, "An American Carol" is an effort to mock left-wing filmmaker Michael Moore and his (real or imagined) disdain for America, while "Religulous" is an attempt to mock organized religion and its adherents.I'm not particularly a fan of either movie (based on style, not substance - I haven't seen either). But I don't like movies that have as an agenda the mockery of people for their beliefs. Just because I might disagree with someone's beliefs doesn't give me the right to mock them. Challenge and question them, yes. But outright mockery? I just think that's in poor taste. But to each his own.
That said, there are a lot of people who will find these movies funny and entertaining, for no other reason than each respective movie supports and reflects the world views of those who like each movie. And with that in mind, I figure that you can identify the general compass of the nation by which movie does better at the box office.
Fortunately, both movies opened the same weekend, so neither movie could attribute a poor performance to an event that took place on its opening weekend that did not take place on the opening weekend of the other movie.
Reviews were not mixed. "Religulous" gained a 68% Fresh Rating at RottenTomatoes. Erstwhile, "An American Carol" received only a 13% Fresh Rating. Translated to normal English - reviewers liked "Religulous" and did not like "An American Carol." In fact, in my observations, I don't think I have seen more than a couple movies ever rate worse than "An American Carol" on RottenTomatoes.When the opening week box-office numbers came out, "An American Carol" opened at number 9, while "Religulous" opened at number 10. Gross numbers reflected "An American Carol" earned $4,354,000, while "Religulous" earned $4,202,216. (You can see the week's charts here in Variety. Be sure to look at the week ending Oct. 9, 2008).
On its face, it appeared that "An American Carol" won out, albeit by a slim margin. But that's not the whole picture. "An American Carol" opened on 1,639 screens, averaging $2,656 per screen. "Religulous" opened on only 502 screens, but averaged $8,371 per screen. Thus, on a per screen basis, "Religulous" won the week by an overwhelming margin. What that translates into is "Religulous" played to packed houses, while "An American Carol" played to roughly 25% filled seats.
Apparently, the abysmal per-screen showing of "An American Carol" has inspired tales of a vast theater conspiracy to skew the ticket sales. Stories abound that theaters took money for "An American Carol" and then printed out tickets for something else.
On NewsBusters, commentator Warner Todd Huston suggests that it "wouldn't surprise [him] if it turned out that certain people were trying to doom this film," in regard to the ticket sales issue. Huston's post also contains a link to the movie's website where people can report fraudulent ticket sales. As of this posting, no such link exists. Huston himself notes the absence of the link in a subsequent posting (wherein he also denies alleging the existence of a conspiracy - I'll let you interpret his above quote however you choose).
Notably, few on the right want to acknowledge that, just maybe, "An American Carol" isn't very good, got poor reviews, and nobody went to see it.
Thursday, October 09, 2008
Country First? Not for John McCain.
This seems to have slipped by people, but in the second presidential debate, John McCain made an extraordinary claim. He knows how to capture Osama bin Laden. Specifically, McCain said "I'll get Osama bin Laden, my friends. I'll get him no matter what, and I know how to do it." (Click here to read and watch. On the left side, scroll down to "Policy on Pakistan" and go to about 7:14 into the video. The text will follow on the right side).
However, it appears that Senator McCain isn't going to tell us how to get bin Laden unless he's elected president. Clearly, John McCain has put country first.
Sadly, the ridiculous nature of the last debate precluded the obvious follow up questions: "How?" and "What do you know that nobody else seems to know?"
Either McCain is lying, or he's a hypocrite who is more concerned about winning an election than helping his country. In either case, there can no longer be any question but that John McCain is not fit to be commander in chief of anything, much less the United States military. A true CIC would subordinate his interest to that of the country's. John McCain is clearly concerned with nothing other than John McCain and winning the White House, national security be damned.
However, it appears that Senator McCain isn't going to tell us how to get bin Laden unless he's elected president. Clearly, John McCain has put country first.
Sadly, the ridiculous nature of the last debate precluded the obvious follow up questions: "How?" and "What do you know that nobody else seems to know?"
Either McCain is lying, or he's a hypocrite who is more concerned about winning an election than helping his country. In either case, there can no longer be any question but that John McCain is not fit to be commander in chief of anything, much less the United States military. A true CIC would subordinate his interest to that of the country's. John McCain is clearly concerned with nothing other than John McCain and winning the White House, national security be damned.
Labels:
country first,
debate,
McCain,
obama,
osama bin laden,
pakistan,
town hall
Tuesday, October 07, 2008
Rush Limbaugh Concedes Obama Victory!
So I'm listening to Rush Limbaugh this morning just to hear the pre-debate spin, and lo-and-behold, he declares Barack Obama is going to win the election.Sort of.
Actually, Limbaugh went on about how the Zogby poll had Obama with a not-quite 3-percent lead over John McCain. Limbaugh then noted that he pays special attention to Zogby because that poll has been accurate in predicting past presidential elections.
As you may recall, yesterday I posted my belief that Obama would win in a landslide, and that part of that opinion comes from John Zogby, who is predicting a Reagan v. Carter, 1980 style landslide victory for Obama.
My hunch is that Limbaugh was unaware that Zogby has preliminarily called the election for Obama, but certainly if Limbaugh believes Zogby gets it right, then he must believe that Obama will win in a landslide.
Of course, I base this entire statement on the old tried-and-true mathematical theorem - if A=B and B=C, then A=C. So it must be true. Limbaugh concedes victory to Obama.
Monday, October 06, 2008
An Obama Landslide?
I said it first (so far as I know believe claim) on October 3rd. But my self-aggrandized genius is probably somewhat overrated, as I clearly am not alone in my belief that this presidential election will end in a landslide victory for Barack Obama.
John Zogby, of the Zogby poll, predicts that this election may be akin to Ronald Reagan's crushing defeat of Jimmy Carter. Likewise, on This Week with George Stephanopoulos, Time Magazine's national political correspondent Karen Tumulty claimed "this is Ronald Reagan, Walter Mondale landslide territory." (Go to about 7:43 into the video).
Noting that I am in no way a fan of or believer in polling (particularly with the rise in the number of people whose only phone is an unlisted cell phone), I guess it gives people something to talk about. So, if you care about polling, this is a pretty cool website - FiveThirtyEight.com. It's like the CNBC of polling data.
John Zogby, of the Zogby poll, predicts that this election may be akin to Ronald Reagan's crushing defeat of Jimmy Carter. Likewise, on This Week with George Stephanopoulos, Time Magazine's national political correspondent Karen Tumulty claimed "this is Ronald Reagan, Walter Mondale landslide territory." (Go to about 7:43 into the video). Noting that I am in no way a fan of or believer in polling (particularly with the rise in the number of people whose only phone is an unlisted cell phone), I guess it gives people something to talk about. So, if you care about polling, this is a pretty cool website - FiveThirtyEight.com. It's like the CNBC of polling data.
Sunday, October 05, 2008
John McCain's New Drinking Game
In a recent comment to a prior post comparing the pre-presidential experience of Barack Obama and Abraham Lincoln, an anonymous commentator began a non-related rant about Obama's voting record. Specifically, the person railed against Obama voting with the Democratic party 90-percent of the time and, therefore, cannot bring the "change" he touts in his campaign.
In truth, Obama votes with his party 96-percent of the time. (Scroll down to "Voting With Party" on left side).
However, John McCain, a self-described "maverick" and reformer, has voted with his party 88.1-percent of the time. Not exactly an agent of "change" either. In fact, a review of this complete list of voting records reflects that there are 31 GOP Senators who have voted against their party more often than John McCain. There are 49 Republican senators. That translates to 63-percent of the GOP Senators whose voting records deviate from party-lines, and thus are greater "mavericks" than McCain.
Two things to bear in mind when considering these figures: (1) Voting "with" your party does not inherently mean you voted "against" the other party, or the administration. For example, the recent financial "rescue" bill was the baby of the GOP White House, and a majority of Senate Democrats and a majority of Senate Republicans voted for it. That would translate in a "voting with party" mark for any candidate that voted in favor.; (2) This does not identify the differences between Obama and McCain - i.e. where did they vote different and where did they vote the same.
John McCain's "maverick" label borders on the ridiculous, but is clearly misleading (at least when engaging in an "apples-to-apples" generalized comparison of McCain's and Obama's voting records). Certainly, McCain has taken some positions well outside his party's agenda (e.g. Gang of 14; McCain-Feingold, to name a few). But cherry-picking doesn't undo the overall record.
On the funny side, during the Vice-Presidential debate, both my wife and I mentioned that we should play a drinking game where we drink every time Sarah Palin said "maverick." Turns out we weren't the only ones with that thought:
In truth, Obama votes with his party 96-percent of the time. (Scroll down to "Voting With Party" on left side).
However, John McCain, a self-described "maverick" and reformer, has voted with his party 88.1-percent of the time. Not exactly an agent of "change" either. In fact, a review of this complete list of voting records reflects that there are 31 GOP Senators who have voted against their party more often than John McCain. There are 49 Republican senators. That translates to 63-percent of the GOP Senators whose voting records deviate from party-lines, and thus are greater "mavericks" than McCain.
Two things to bear in mind when considering these figures: (1) Voting "with" your party does not inherently mean you voted "against" the other party, or the administration. For example, the recent financial "rescue" bill was the baby of the GOP White House, and a majority of Senate Democrats and a majority of Senate Republicans voted for it. That would translate in a "voting with party" mark for any candidate that voted in favor.; (2) This does not identify the differences between Obama and McCain - i.e. where did they vote different and where did they vote the same.
John McCain's "maverick" label borders on the ridiculous, but is clearly misleading (at least when engaging in an "apples-to-apples" generalized comparison of McCain's and Obama's voting records). Certainly, McCain has taken some positions well outside his party's agenda (e.g. Gang of 14; McCain-Feingold, to name a few). But cherry-picking doesn't undo the overall record.
On the funny side, during the Vice-Presidential debate, both my wife and I mentioned that we should play a drinking game where we drink every time Sarah Palin said "maverick." Turns out we weren't the only ones with that thought:
Tuesday, September 23, 2008
Palin's "Experience" Exposed
As you may have heard by now, while Sarah Palin was mayor of Wasilla, Alaska, the town charged rape victims for the cost of their rape kits. A rape kit is the forensic/medical exam and testing done to deterimine the identity of the rapist - sort of like dusting for fingerprints, but more invasive and unpleasant.
When the town's police chief refused to end the practice, the Alaska legislature debated and passed a bill to forbid it, and specifically targeted Wasilla.
The debate over the practice has focused on whether Palin knew about and, by implication, condoned the practice. The general consensus is that there is no evidence Palin had direct knowledge of the practice.
That seems to miss the point. The significance of the story is not whether Palin condoned such an abhorent practice. Rather, it is that such a thing could occur in her town while she was mayor, and apparently she knew nothing about it. What kind of leadership is that?
And isn't it difficult to believe that the mayor of a town being targeted by the state legislature doesn't know that her town is so targeted? Again, what kind of leadership is that? Did she live in a bubble?
Palin criticized Barack Obama's stint as a community organizer by noting that one of the key differences between that job and being a small-town mayor was that the may had "actual responsibilities." If that is true, then when will we hear Palin take "actual responsibility" for the actions of her town's police chief, the actions of her mayoral staff in (presumably) keeping her in the dark, and her own actions in reviewing and approving budgets that reflected the practice without, it would seem, actually reading those budgets? And what kind of leader doesn't know this is going on?
Clearly, not all "experience" is created equal.
When the town's police chief refused to end the practice, the Alaska legislature debated and passed a bill to forbid it, and specifically targeted Wasilla.
The debate over the practice has focused on whether Palin knew about and, by implication, condoned the practice. The general consensus is that there is no evidence Palin had direct knowledge of the practice.
That seems to miss the point. The significance of the story is not whether Palin condoned such an abhorent practice. Rather, it is that such a thing could occur in her town while she was mayor, and apparently she knew nothing about it. What kind of leadership is that?
And isn't it difficult to believe that the mayor of a town being targeted by the state legislature doesn't know that her town is so targeted? Again, what kind of leadership is that? Did she live in a bubble?
Palin criticized Barack Obama's stint as a community organizer by noting that one of the key differences between that job and being a small-town mayor was that the may had "actual responsibilities." If that is true, then when will we hear Palin take "actual responsibility" for the actions of her town's police chief, the actions of her mayoral staff in (presumably) keeping her in the dark, and her own actions in reviewing and approving budgets that reflected the practice without, it would seem, actually reading those budgets? And what kind of leader doesn't know this is going on?
Clearly, not all "experience" is created equal.
Labels:
community organizer,
experience,
leadership,
obama,
palin,
rape kits,
wasilla
More Fox News Just Making Stuff Up.
Came across this today from Fox News' John Gibson, in a piece about Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac:
In fact, Fannie Mae was created in 1938, as part of FDR's "New Deal." Bill Clinton was born in 1946. I'm hard pressed to grasp how Fannie was a creation of the Clinton White House, when it was created 8 years before Clinton was even born.
Freddie Mac was created in 1970, during Richard Nixon's presidency. For those of you from Mars, Nixon was a Republican.
Gibson was right in that both entities were created by Democrat-controlled congresses. So, even a blind pig occasionally finds a truffle.
"Fannie and Freddie have been creations of the congressional Democrats and the Clinton White House, designed to make mortgages available to more people and, as it turns out, some people who couldn't afford them."Really? Maybe Mr. Gibson should try fact-checking his commentary. On the other hand, if he was relegated to speaking the truth, he wouldn't have much to say (as would be the case with most of Fox News).
In fact, Fannie Mae was created in 1938, as part of FDR's "New Deal." Bill Clinton was born in 1946. I'm hard pressed to grasp how Fannie was a creation of the Clinton White House, when it was created 8 years before Clinton was even born.
Freddie Mac was created in 1970, during Richard Nixon's presidency. For those of you from Mars, Nixon was a Republican.
Gibson was right in that both entities were created by Democrat-controlled congresses. So, even a blind pig occasionally finds a truffle.
Monday, September 22, 2008
The subtle genius of SNL's Palin incest skit
On Saturday, September 20, 2008, Saturday Night Live ran a skit in which reporters from the New York Times were discussing being assigned to go to Alaska to dig up dirt on Sarah Palin. The relevant dialogue went as follows:
On its surface, the skit was designed to poke fun at the NYT and other liberal media efforts to discredit Palin, while seriously failing to understand the world outside their cloistered Manhatten existence. Although you would think conservatives would enjoy watching the NYT be skewered, instead they are up in arms over how inappropriate it was to suggest Palin's husband and daughter was engaged in an incestuous relationship.
Fox News is on the story of course. In this somewhat rambling "report" about the controversy, the non-news network somehow tries to tie the fabricated incest story with the all-to-real story of Sarah Palin's Downs-Syndrome baby, and perhaps suggest the skit was intended to give voice to some bizarre conspiracy theories that the baby is actually that of the Palin's eldest daughter Bristol.
The beauty of the skit was saved for the final headlines though. First the paper creates a "what if" rumor based on nothing but ignorance of Alaska and Alaskans, then reports as news the fact that its phony story has not yet been disproven. That, in a nutshell, is what Fox News does every day - except they don't use a live audience or a laugh track.
Sadly, I don't keep a journal of all the examples I see of this on Fox News, which I confess to watching for the entertainment value - I am often on the edge of my seat waiting to see how they'll distort reality this time. Here are some examples.
First, on June 6, E.D. Hill, on her show "America's Pulse" characterized the Michelle and Barack Obama "fist bump" as "A fist bump? A pound? A terrorist fist jab? The gesture everyone seems to interpret differently."
Following that lede, after a commercial break Hill returned with an interview with body language "expert" Janine Driver and never again mentions the "terrorist fist jab" interpretation, and certainly Driver says nothing remotely similar. (Hill and her show were cancelled within days, so credit to Fox where it's due).
Another great example comes from Megan Kelly, whose apparent qualification to work on TV is she's blonde and kinda hot. (Note - Megan Kelly is also a graduate of Albany Law School and worked for a brief period for Jones Day, one of the world's largest law firms).
In her speech to the Democratic National Conventinon, Michelle Obama said "the world as it is just won't do." She then went on to discuss how people have to fight for a better world.
In her subsequent "analysis," Kelly says this:
Really? If I replace someone's words with other words, then I can ask whether there are issues surrounding the story I just made up? And then, perhaps, I can continue to note that, although there is no evidence to prove my fabricated story, there is no evidence to disprove it, either.
Reporter: Uh, what about the husband? You know he's doing those daughters. I mean, come on, it's Alaska!
Editor: He very well could be. Admittedly there is no evidence of that, but, on the other hand, there is no convincing evidence to the contrary. And these are just some of the lingering questions about Governor Palin.The skit ends with a shot of a NYT mockup with a banner headline reading: "In Small Alaska Town, Doubts Still Linger." Halfway down the page is another headline, two columns wide, that reads: "While No Direct Evidence of Incest in Palin Family Emerges, Counter Evidence Remains Agonizongly Elusive."
On its surface, the skit was designed to poke fun at the NYT and other liberal media efforts to discredit Palin, while seriously failing to understand the world outside their cloistered Manhatten existence. Although you would think conservatives would enjoy watching the NYT be skewered, instead they are up in arms over how inappropriate it was to suggest Palin's husband and daughter was engaged in an incestuous relationship.
Fox News is on the story of course. In this somewhat rambling "report" about the controversy, the non-news network somehow tries to tie the fabricated incest story with the all-to-real story of Sarah Palin's Downs-Syndrome baby, and perhaps suggest the skit was intended to give voice to some bizarre conspiracy theories that the baby is actually that of the Palin's eldest daughter Bristol.
The beauty of the skit was saved for the final headlines though. First the paper creates a "what if" rumor based on nothing but ignorance of Alaska and Alaskans, then reports as news the fact that its phony story has not yet been disproven. That, in a nutshell, is what Fox News does every day - except they don't use a live audience or a laugh track.
Sadly, I don't keep a journal of all the examples I see of this on Fox News, which I confess to watching for the entertainment value - I am often on the edge of my seat waiting to see how they'll distort reality this time. Here are some examples.
First, on June 6, E.D. Hill, on her show "America's Pulse" characterized the Michelle and Barack Obama "fist bump" as "A fist bump? A pound? A terrorist fist jab? The gesture everyone seems to interpret differently."Following that lede, after a commercial break Hill returned with an interview with body language "expert" Janine Driver and never again mentions the "terrorist fist jab" interpretation, and certainly Driver says nothing remotely similar. (Hill and her show were cancelled within days, so credit to Fox where it's due).
Watch it here:
In her speech to the Democratic National Conventinon, Michelle Obama said "the world as it is just won't do." She then went on to discuss how people have to fight for a better world.
In her subsequent "analysis," Kelly says this:
Megan Kelly: If you replace "world" with "country," you're back to the same debate, arguably, you've been having about Michelle Obama's feelings about this country.
Really? If I replace someone's words with other words, then I can ask whether there are issues surrounding the story I just made up? And then, perhaps, I can continue to note that, although there is no evidence to prove my fabricated story, there is no evidence to disprove it, either.
Watch Stephen Colbert illustrate the point better than I:
Notably, Hume doesn't try to say Obama is a Muslim. Rather, he engages in the "if we put it out there and nobody disproves it, maybe it is true" practice that is the hallmark of what passes for reporting on Fox News. Worse for Hume, turns out it's not true anyway. The last half of the sentence is a fabrication, and you can listen to the actual interview here. You'll note that Malik Obama never says what Hume and Fox said he did.
In this broadcast, former journalist Britt Hume reads a story that begins by restating that Barack Obama and his campaign have gone out of their way to remind people that Obama is a christian, not a muslim. Then, Hume notes that the Jerusalem Post reported an interview with Obama's half brother Malik. The Post story, as reported by Hume and Fox, said "if elected his brother will be a good president for the Jewish people, despite his Muslim background."
Notably, Hume doesn't try to say Obama is a Muslim. Rather, he engages in the "if we put it out there and nobody disproves it, maybe it is true" practice that is the hallmark of what passes for reporting on Fox News. Worse for Hume, turns out it's not true anyway. The last half of the sentence is a fabrication, and you can listen to the actual interview here. You'll note that Malik Obama never says what Hume and Fox said he did.
So kudos to SNL for its sly (even if unintended) slap at Fox News and its mindless followers. Lies, and in particular outrageous lies, are no less wrong and immoral when they are couched in the false pretense of "just wondering" and then left to grow on their own, like a noxious weed. Sucks to be on the receiving end of that tactic for once, huh. (And a thumbs down to NBC for cowardly removing the clip from YouTube and failing to post it on its own website).
Tuesday, September 16, 2008
Busting the Palin Bubble
It was fun ride, to be sure, but the Sarah Palin bubble of excitement that came with her unexpected (by anybody) nomination for the Republican vice-presidential slot appears to be bursting right before our eyes.
Palin has been on the stump for a good couple weeks now, and has yet to give a new speech. She continues to lie about the Bridge to Nowhere, she continues to lie about her opposition to earmarks, she continues to lie about being a fiscally responsible governor/mayor. Worse, she continues to make these lies after they have been universally debunked. However, Palin, John McCain and the rest of the GOP machine have apparently bought into the time-tested truth espoused by Vladimir Lenin - "A lie told often enough becomes truth."
The GOP has borrowed from Lenin's playbook before, leaking the "Obama is a muslim" or "Obama is not a citizen" or similar falsehoods through their proxies, and then disavowing responsibility while coyly responding "That's for Senator Obama to address," thereby tacitly re-asking the question and giving it an air of authenticity.
I'm not sure I've ever seen a campaign for any office at any level delve to the depths of the McCain camp. And I am very troubled. I have always had a high opinion of John McCain. I believe his record of running against the Beltway Insiders is, by and large, pretty admirable. Sure he's had his failings - even significant ones (i.e. the Keating Five), but I believed he learned from that and become a better senator because of it. I disagreed with McCain during this campaign on the important issues - the economy, taxes, health care. I disagree with his assessment of the war in Iraq, with the "success" of the surge (which I still consider dubious at best), and his non-strategy for exit.
But now, McCain has turned his campaign over to a group of hacks who, in any other election, would be salivating at the chance to light up McCain for being too liberal, too much of an insider, or just plain too old. They, in turn, have taken the campaign into an area that even Karl Rove has decried as beyond the pale. That's something. When even the devil himself says you've crossed the line, what do you do?
Apparently, if you are John McCain, you go on "The View" and expose the fact that you have no idea what your campaign is saying or doing. And now I don't know what to think of John McCain. Either he has, as one Obama staffer said, decided he'd rather lose his integrity than lose an election, or he is now exposed for the weak, bumbling old man being led by the nose that I sort of thought he was at the outset.
In either case, the magnitude of his and Palin's lies are beginning to unravel the whole aura of excitement and remove their stolen mantra of "change." Worse for McCain, Palin's handlers won't let her talk to the media until the media is nice to her (which is clear evidence of her ability to lead), won't let her cooperate with the "Troopergate" prove in Alaska (just like a real reformer), won't release her tax records, and won't let her go off script, even if that script has grown tired and has been rejected as an outright lie.
McCain should have picked Mitt Romney. There would have been a short run of ads showing Romney and McCain tearing each other up at debates and on the stump, but that would have passed and things would have settled down, allowing McCain-Romney to run on their records and issues. They would have posed a formidable challenge to Obama-Biden. But McCain-Palin is quickly turning into a punchline the magnitude of which I don't recall having ever seen.
Palin has been on the stump for a good couple weeks now, and has yet to give a new speech. She continues to lie about the Bridge to Nowhere, she continues to lie about her opposition to earmarks, she continues to lie about being a fiscally responsible governor/mayor. Worse, she continues to make these lies after they have been universally debunked. However, Palin, John McCain and the rest of the GOP machine have apparently bought into the time-tested truth espoused by Vladimir Lenin - "A lie told often enough becomes truth."
The GOP has borrowed from Lenin's playbook before, leaking the "Obama is a muslim" or "Obama is not a citizen" or similar falsehoods through their proxies, and then disavowing responsibility while coyly responding "That's for Senator Obama to address," thereby tacitly re-asking the question and giving it an air of authenticity.
I'm not sure I've ever seen a campaign for any office at any level delve to the depths of the McCain camp. And I am very troubled. I have always had a high opinion of John McCain. I believe his record of running against the Beltway Insiders is, by and large, pretty admirable. Sure he's had his failings - even significant ones (i.e. the Keating Five), but I believed he learned from that and become a better senator because of it. I disagreed with McCain during this campaign on the important issues - the economy, taxes, health care. I disagree with his assessment of the war in Iraq, with the "success" of the surge (which I still consider dubious at best), and his non-strategy for exit.
But now, McCain has turned his campaign over to a group of hacks who, in any other election, would be salivating at the chance to light up McCain for being too liberal, too much of an insider, or just plain too old. They, in turn, have taken the campaign into an area that even Karl Rove has decried as beyond the pale. That's something. When even the devil himself says you've crossed the line, what do you do?
Apparently, if you are John McCain, you go on "The View" and expose the fact that you have no idea what your campaign is saying or doing. And now I don't know what to think of John McCain. Either he has, as one Obama staffer said, decided he'd rather lose his integrity than lose an election, or he is now exposed for the weak, bumbling old man being led by the nose that I sort of thought he was at the outset.
In either case, the magnitude of his and Palin's lies are beginning to unravel the whole aura of excitement and remove their stolen mantra of "change." Worse for McCain, Palin's handlers won't let her talk to the media until the media is nice to her (which is clear evidence of her ability to lead), won't let her cooperate with the "Troopergate" prove in Alaska (just like a real reformer), won't release her tax records, and won't let her go off script, even if that script has grown tired and has been rejected as an outright lie.
McCain should have picked Mitt Romney. There would have been a short run of ads showing Romney and McCain tearing each other up at debates and on the stump, but that would have passed and things would have settled down, allowing McCain-Romney to run on their records and issues. They would have posed a formidable challenge to Obama-Biden. But McCain-Palin is quickly turning into a punchline the magnitude of which I don't recall having ever seen.
Wednesday, September 10, 2008
Kissing Pigs
Not that this is any big deal, but I sometimes wonder if the media, and perhaps most of America (or at least, America as it appears in the media) lives in a cave (or a small box).
In a campaign speech the other day, Barack Obama said, in regard to the GOP's questionable usurpation of the "change" theme, that if you put lipstick on a pig it's still a pig. Now, I don't know how many times in my life I've heard that phrase. My favorite variation is that a pig in a dress is still a pig, but whatever.
Apparently some ignorant folk believe the remark was intended to call GOP Veep Wannabe Sarah Palin a "pig." This, because in her rousing yet hollow convention speech, she mentioned that the difference between a hockey-mom and a pit bull was lipstick. It was a stupid line then, and it remains a stupid line now.
But in order to believe the Obama comment was somehow formulated to respond to Palin's stupid line, you have to have lived in a cave (or a small box) for basically your entire life. Otherwise, you would know that the lipsticked pig remark is an old-school, tried-and-true, time-tested and pundit-approved colliquialism that is shorthand for you can't make a substantively bad thing good by applying cosmetic changes.
In this case, the Obama comment was meant to say that you can't change the tired, hackneyed, tried-and-failed ideas of the GOP by adding an exciting and energizing personality into the mix. (Or, maybe he was saying that you can make John McCain look like a maverick by propping him up next to a sexy librarian - I don't know).
But seriously, to those who are currently foaming at the mouth over this, stop being stupid.
And eat some bacon.
In a campaign speech the other day, Barack Obama said, in regard to the GOP's questionable usurpation of the "change" theme, that if you put lipstick on a pig it's still a pig. Now, I don't know how many times in my life I've heard that phrase. My favorite variation is that a pig in a dress is still a pig, but whatever.
Apparently some ignorant folk believe the remark was intended to call GOP Veep Wannabe Sarah Palin a "pig." This, because in her rousing yet hollow convention speech, she mentioned that the difference between a hockey-mom and a pit bull was lipstick. It was a stupid line then, and it remains a stupid line now.
But in order to believe the Obama comment was somehow formulated to respond to Palin's stupid line, you have to have lived in a cave (or a small box) for basically your entire life. Otherwise, you would know that the lipsticked pig remark is an old-school, tried-and-true, time-tested and pundit-approved colliquialism that is shorthand for you can't make a substantively bad thing good by applying cosmetic changes.
In this case, the Obama comment was meant to say that you can't change the tired, hackneyed, tried-and-failed ideas of the GOP by adding an exciting and energizing personality into the mix. (Or, maybe he was saying that you can make John McCain look like a maverick by propping him up next to a sexy librarian - I don't know).
But seriously, to those who are currently foaming at the mouth over this, stop being stupid.
And eat some bacon.
Thursday, September 04, 2008
Who Ya Gonna Tax? BIG OIL!
A funny thing happened on the way to the gas station today - Big Oil made more money. I'd sure like some that.
As it turns out, I'm likely to get my wish regardless of who is elected President.
Barack Obama wants to institute a "windfall profits tax" on the oil companies. I don't know what constitutes a "windfall" profit as opposed to a regular, or even large, profit. But he wants to send me a check with the money he takes from the oil companies, who I am sure won't miss it.
But, like with almost everything Obama discusses so far, it's pretty words and happy talk - good speech, no action - at least not yet.
On the other hand, Sarah Palin, the GOP's veep nominee, has already played the roll of Robin Hood. In Alaska, Palin seriously jacked taxes for the oil companies doing business in her state, then distributed the money to the people in the form of $1,200.00 rebate checks. Presumably, that also made it easier to manage the state's budget.
So I guess Obama and Palin aren't so different after all. Because I am certain that Palin's Great Alaskan Handout was not overt political pandering, but rather epitomizes her strongly-held conviction that it is her role to ensure government takes what it needs from big oil (or big business for that matter) and redistribute some to the masses while keeping the rest for itself.
Balanced budgets are just around the corner!
As it turns out, I'm likely to get my wish regardless of who is elected President.
Barack Obama wants to institute a "windfall profits tax" on the oil companies. I don't know what constitutes a "windfall" profit as opposed to a regular, or even large, profit. But he wants to send me a check with the money he takes from the oil companies, who I am sure won't miss it.
But, like with almost everything Obama discusses so far, it's pretty words and happy talk - good speech, no action - at least not yet.
On the other hand, Sarah Palin, the GOP's veep nominee, has already played the roll of Robin Hood. In Alaska, Palin seriously jacked taxes for the oil companies doing business in her state, then distributed the money to the people in the form of $1,200.00 rebate checks. Presumably, that also made it easier to manage the state's budget.
So I guess Obama and Palin aren't so different after all. Because I am certain that Palin's Great Alaskan Handout was not overt political pandering, but rather epitomizes her strongly-held conviction that it is her role to ensure government takes what it needs from big oil (or big business for that matter) and redistribute some to the masses while keeping the rest for itself.
Balanced budgets are just around the corner!
Wednesday, September 03, 2008
Obama "least experienced candidate"?
Wow - it's been three months since I've posted anything. Not for lack of interest, just lack of time.
Anyhow, among the many things churning in my turbid little brain is the questioning of Barack Obama's experience and whether is qualified to be President.
Last night, I heard this line from presidential wannabe and former Senate washout Fred Thompson (R-TN), who apparently took time away from his nap to speak at the Republican National Convention. In his speech, Thompson said that Obama was "the most liberal, most inexperienced nominee to ever run for President."
Fred, you're a good actor. But you're also an idiot.
Here's a little comparison for you Fred, using one of your honored own (unless you're from the South, then maybe not so honored).
Barack Obama
8 years in Illinois Senate (1996-2004)
3.5 years in U.S. Senate (2005-2008)
Democratic nominee for President (2008)
Abraham Lincoln
8 years in Illinois House (1834-1842)
2 years in U.S. House (1846-1848)
Republican nominee for President (1860)
Note Lincoln's 12-year absence from elected office. No way he could get elected today.
Obama the "most inexperienced nominee to ever run for President"? Other than Abraham Lincoln, perhaps. But I don't think Lincoln turned out so bad, and he was a decent war-time Commander-in-Chief (at least he won his war).
I note, Fred, that you ran for President with only 9 years experience in any elected office (U.S. Senate). That's less elected-office experience than either Obama or Lincoln. Something about people living in glass houses not throwing stones comes to mind.
Lastly, Fred, please -- I know you didn't write the speech (unless you did), but people who speak English as a first language would not say "most inexperienced." The correct term is "least experienced." Ignorant stupidity is one thing. Illiterate ignorant stupidity is simply intolerable.
Anyhow, among the many things churning in my turbid little brain is the questioning of Barack Obama's experience and whether is qualified to be President.
Last night, I heard this line from presidential wannabe and former Senate washout Fred Thompson (R-TN), who apparently took time away from his nap to speak at the Republican National Convention. In his speech, Thompson said that Obama was "the most liberal, most inexperienced nominee to ever run for President."
Fred, you're a good actor. But you're also an idiot.
Here's a little comparison for you Fred, using one of your honored own (unless you're from the South, then maybe not so honored).
Barack Obama
8 years in Illinois Senate (1996-2004)
3.5 years in U.S. Senate (2005-2008)
Democratic nominee for President (2008)
Abraham Lincoln
8 years in Illinois House (1834-1842)
2 years in U.S. House (1846-1848)
Republican nominee for President (1860)
Note Lincoln's 12-year absence from elected office. No way he could get elected today.
Obama the "most inexperienced nominee to ever run for President"? Other than Abraham Lincoln, perhaps. But I don't think Lincoln turned out so bad, and he was a decent war-time Commander-in-Chief (at least he won his war).
I note, Fred, that you ran for President with only 9 years experience in any elected office (U.S. Senate). That's less elected-office experience than either Obama or Lincoln. Something about people living in glass houses not throwing stones comes to mind.
Lastly, Fred, please -- I know you didn't write the speech (unless you did), but people who speak English as a first language would not say "most inexperienced." The correct term is "least experienced." Ignorant stupidity is one thing. Illiterate ignorant stupidity is simply intolerable.
Labels:
experience,
fred thompson,
lincoln,
obama,
president
Tuesday, June 10, 2008
McCain: Bring Back Prohibition
Further distancing himself from his Democratic opponent, Woodrow Wilson, presumptive Republican presidential nominee John McCain has declared that, if elected president, he will bring back Prohibition.
Or, he was signaling his intent to bring on Mitt Romney as a vice-presidential running mate.
Or, he was channeling Homer Simpson.
You decide:
I want to know whether he intends to use earmarks to veto the beers, or if he will only veto beers that contain earmarks, but not other beers. If he intends to use earmarks to veto the beers, will he dip his ear in ink, or will it be dabbed on by an ATF agent? If the latter, will it be okay if my beer contains one earmark, but not two? And why would I be putting my beer up to my ear anyway?
Or, he was signaling his intent to bring on Mitt Romney as a vice-presidential running mate.
Or, he was channeling Homer Simpson.
You decide:
I want to know whether he intends to use earmarks to veto the beers, or if he will only veto beers that contain earmarks, but not other beers. If he intends to use earmarks to veto the beers, will he dip his ear in ink, or will it be dabbed on by an ATF agent? If the latter, will it be okay if my beer contains one earmark, but not two? And why would I be putting my beer up to my ear anyway?
Labels:
beer,
earmarks,
Homer Simpson,
McCain,
Mitt Romney,
president,
prohibition,
veto
Monday, June 02, 2008
Cool Workout Playlist

Now that Tina bought me a new iPod Touch for my birthday (Thank You Tina!), I came up with a 30-minute playlist for running. Songs are designed for a 5-minute warm-up, about 6:30 in fast jog / slow run, about 10-minutes of faster running (about 6 on my treadmill), followed by 9-minutes of warm down.
Playlist is:
Hells Bells - AC/DC (warm up)
Crawling In The Dark - Hoobastank (fast jog)
Paralyzer - Finger Eleven (faster jog / slow run)
Inside The Fire - Disturbed (run)
Afterlife - Avenged Sevenfold (run faster - sprint the solos if you can)
Children of the Sea - Black Sabbath (catch your breath with some Dio)
Over You - Daughtry (relax, walk it out)
The whole thing is like 30.4 minutes, which is the minimum cardio you're supposed to get each day (not that I do). The nice thing about keeping a fixed playlist for running, rather than mixing it up each time, is you soon get to know exactly where you are the run and how much longer you have to go. And at least for me, it's all about the light at the end of the tunnel.
It's All Up To Missouri
USA Today has a really cool electoral college tracker where you can assign states to Obama and McCain and see where each has to win in order to reach 270 electoral votes and win the general election.
I assigned states based primarily on history voting patterns, which resulted in several Bush states from 2004 swinging back to their historical Democratic-leaning trends.
My result? It all comes down to Missouri.
I gave Obama the following states: Washington, Oregon, California, Hawaii, New Mexico, Nevada, Minnesota, Iowa, Wisconsin, Illinois, Michigan, and the entire Northeast (from Maryland north, including D.C.). The result is 269 electoral votes.
Everything else I gave to McCain, including Missouri. The result - 269 electoral votes. A dead tie.
(I have no idea what happens in the event of a tie, and don't recall seeing that covered in the Constitution).
In 1992 and 1996, Missouri went for Bill Clinton. In 2000 and 2004, it went for Bush.
Now, I'm going to borrow a oft-cited (but substantively sophmoric) argument used by Clinton - that she has won the states Dems need to win the general election. On my map, the only legitimate battleground state is Missouri - a state that Obama won by a mere 10,000 votes (1% difference). Thus, Obama wins the only state that matters - the only state in contest. Giving Missouri to Obama results in a 280-258 win for Obama. Notably, it also results in the complete political marginalization of the South, which for years has been considered "must-win" territory for either party to win the White House.
Some states, like Michigan (which isn't really included in the primary results), California, Pennsylvania and New York all went for Clinton. But those states are unshakable Democratic locks, and have all gone that way for the past four presidential elections. Obama will win those without breaking a sweat.
Clinton's argument loses more luster when you view my map and realize that I have given McCain Ohio and Florida, both of which were obviously pivotal in the past two elections. Those are two of the big states that Clinton says she can win, and that Dems have to win. 'cept they don't have to win them (at least not on my map).
This year, as goes Missouri, goes the White House. And Missouri goes to Obama.
I assigned states based primarily on history voting patterns, which resulted in several Bush states from 2004 swinging back to their historical Democratic-leaning trends.
My result? It all comes down to Missouri.
I gave Obama the following states: Washington, Oregon, California, Hawaii, New Mexico, Nevada, Minnesota, Iowa, Wisconsin, Illinois, Michigan, and the entire Northeast (from Maryland north, including D.C.). The result is 269 electoral votes.
Everything else I gave to McCain, including Missouri. The result - 269 electoral votes. A dead tie.
(I have no idea what happens in the event of a tie, and don't recall seeing that covered in the Constitution).
In 1992 and 1996, Missouri went for Bill Clinton. In 2000 and 2004, it went for Bush.
Now, I'm going to borrow a oft-cited (but substantively sophmoric) argument used by Clinton - that she has won the states Dems need to win the general election. On my map, the only legitimate battleground state is Missouri - a state that Obama won by a mere 10,000 votes (1% difference). Thus, Obama wins the only state that matters - the only state in contest. Giving Missouri to Obama results in a 280-258 win for Obama. Notably, it also results in the complete political marginalization of the South, which for years has been considered "must-win" territory for either party to win the White House.
Some states, like Michigan (which isn't really included in the primary results), California, Pennsylvania and New York all went for Clinton. But those states are unshakable Democratic locks, and have all gone that way for the past four presidential elections. Obama will win those without breaking a sweat.
Clinton's argument loses more luster when you view my map and realize that I have given McCain Ohio and Florida, both of which were obviously pivotal in the past two elections. Those are two of the big states that Clinton says she can win, and that Dems have to win. 'cept they don't have to win them (at least not on my map).
This year, as goes Missouri, goes the White House. And Missouri goes to Obama.
Labels:
electoral college,
general election,
McCain,
missouri,
obama,
president,
voting
New Political Math
Much like the Democratic primary itself, the bizarre death-spiral of the Clinton campaign continues unabated. Clinton and her cadre of hanger-oners continue to press the "we are winning the popular vote" claim.
Oddly, Clinton makes that argument using the primary vote from Puerto Rico. Apparently nobody has told Clinton that Puerto Rico doesn't count. The island gets to vote in the primary solely because the DNC wanted to throw a bone to various U.S. protectorates and territories (there's a primary in Guam, too). However, at the end of the day, in the only election that matters - the general election in November - Puerto Ricans can't vote. Consequently, nobody cares how they voted in a non-binding and irrelevant advisory vote. Counting those votes is sort of like a basketball team counting its pre-game warm-up shots toward the final score of the actual game.
Clinton should be happy that she managed to neuter the Rules and Bylaws Committee of the DNC (and by extension, the DNC itself) by badgering it into giving her delegates that should never have been awarded to anybody. Apparently destroying her party's ability to run its own show is not enough. Seriously, her scorched-earth policy would do Stalin proud.
Oddly, Clinton makes that argument using the primary vote from Puerto Rico. Apparently nobody has told Clinton that Puerto Rico doesn't count. The island gets to vote in the primary solely because the DNC wanted to throw a bone to various U.S. protectorates and territories (there's a primary in Guam, too). However, at the end of the day, in the only election that matters - the general election in November - Puerto Ricans can't vote. Consequently, nobody cares how they voted in a non-binding and irrelevant advisory vote. Counting those votes is sort of like a basketball team counting its pre-game warm-up shots toward the final score of the actual game.
Clinton should be happy that she managed to neuter the Rules and Bylaws Committee of the DNC (and by extension, the DNC itself) by badgering it into giving her delegates that should never have been awarded to anybody. Apparently destroying her party's ability to run its own show is not enough. Seriously, her scorched-earth policy would do Stalin proud.
Labels:
convention,
delegates,
democratic national committee,
dnc,
florida,
michigan,
popular vote,
rules,
vote
Friday, May 30, 2008
Primary confusion
On Saturday, the rules committee of the Democratic National Committee (DNC) is going to meet to discuss the "Florigan" problem - namely what to do with the votes of primary voters in Florida and Michigan.
As you may (and should) know, Florida and Michigan decided to hold their primaries early, in contravention of DNC rules. The DNC told those states that if they went forward with the early primaries, their delegates would not be seated at the convention in August, meaning their primaries would be meaningless.
All of the Democratic contenders (Clinton, Obama, Edwards) agreed to those rules. Nobody campaigned in Florida, and Obama and Edwards weren't even on the ballot in Michigan. Not surpisingly, Clinton won both states, but didn't make any noise about the votes not counting until it became apparent that her coronation was going to be challenged. Suddenly she had a change of heart, and demanded a rule change mid-game, picking up the rallying cry of "count every vote."
Coming to her defense are political hacks and wannabe hacks who are crying foul, alleging that the failure to count those states' primary votes somehow runs afoul of, if not the Constitution, at least Constitutional principles.
But they are wrong.
You see, there is no right to vote for a party nominee. The DNC and RNC can both simply send approved slates to the convention. Of course, others can appear at the convention as well. Then, the delegates at the conventions get to debate and argue and, ultimately, vote for a candidate.
In fact, that's how it used to work. There were no primaries. But somewhere along the line, the parties decided that rather than have drawn-out, war-like conventions full of back-room deals and viscious party-infighting, they'd let the people select the nominee. Thus, the primary system.
Thus, the primary system is simply a creature created by the political parties solely for the purpose of ensuring nominees who have shown an ability to garner popular support outside of the party headquarters. Because it is a process they created, it is a process that they can control in any manner they chose. The creation of superdelegates is one example - they exist solely to serve as a counter balance to the popular vote in order to prevent voters from selecting a total loser.
Note also that pledged delegates don't have to vote the way they are pledged. Truly, your vote counts for nothing more than a suggestion.
But what this means is that you have no "right" to participate in a primary because you have no "right" to a primary to begin with. In other words, the primary is nothing more than the DNC asking for your advice on who should be its nominee. The DNC doesn't have to follow your advice, or even pay it any heed. It can create and modify its rules as it sees fit.
By not counting the votes of states who didn't follow party rules, the DNC is not dis-enfranchising anybody. It's simply enforcing its rules, and tomorrow it could change its rules to do away with the primary system all together. And there is NOTHING you or anybody else could do about it.
Saturday will see the DNC face the most serious challenge to its authority, and perhaps its very existence as a viable political party. For if a political party cannot establish and enforce its own rules, then it serves no purpose other than to bend to the will of whoever makes the most noise. If the DNC cannot enforce its sanctions against Michigan and Florida and seats those delegates, that will send the signal to every other state that, they too can ignore the DNC and schedule their primaries however and whenever they want, knowing full well that at the end of the day, the DNC rules have no teeth. Hopefully, the DNC will show some backbone on Saturday.
As you may (and should) know, Florida and Michigan decided to hold their primaries early, in contravention of DNC rules. The DNC told those states that if they went forward with the early primaries, their delegates would not be seated at the convention in August, meaning their primaries would be meaningless.
All of the Democratic contenders (Clinton, Obama, Edwards) agreed to those rules. Nobody campaigned in Florida, and Obama and Edwards weren't even on the ballot in Michigan. Not surpisingly, Clinton won both states, but didn't make any noise about the votes not counting until it became apparent that her coronation was going to be challenged. Suddenly she had a change of heart, and demanded a rule change mid-game, picking up the rallying cry of "count every vote."
Coming to her defense are political hacks and wannabe hacks who are crying foul, alleging that the failure to count those states' primary votes somehow runs afoul of, if not the Constitution, at least Constitutional principles.
But they are wrong.
You see, there is no right to vote for a party nominee. The DNC and RNC can both simply send approved slates to the convention. Of course, others can appear at the convention as well. Then, the delegates at the conventions get to debate and argue and, ultimately, vote for a candidate.
In fact, that's how it used to work. There were no primaries. But somewhere along the line, the parties decided that rather than have drawn-out, war-like conventions full of back-room deals and viscious party-infighting, they'd let the people select the nominee. Thus, the primary system.
Thus, the primary system is simply a creature created by the political parties solely for the purpose of ensuring nominees who have shown an ability to garner popular support outside of the party headquarters. Because it is a process they created, it is a process that they can control in any manner they chose. The creation of superdelegates is one example - they exist solely to serve as a counter balance to the popular vote in order to prevent voters from selecting a total loser.
Note also that pledged delegates don't have to vote the way they are pledged. Truly, your vote counts for nothing more than a suggestion.
But what this means is that you have no "right" to participate in a primary because you have no "right" to a primary to begin with. In other words, the primary is nothing more than the DNC asking for your advice on who should be its nominee. The DNC doesn't have to follow your advice, or even pay it any heed. It can create and modify its rules as it sees fit.
By not counting the votes of states who didn't follow party rules, the DNC is not dis-enfranchising anybody. It's simply enforcing its rules, and tomorrow it could change its rules to do away with the primary system all together. And there is NOTHING you or anybody else could do about it.
Saturday will see the DNC face the most serious challenge to its authority, and perhaps its very existence as a viable political party. For if a political party cannot establish and enforce its own rules, then it serves no purpose other than to bend to the will of whoever makes the most noise. If the DNC cannot enforce its sanctions against Michigan and Florida and seats those delegates, that will send the signal to every other state that, they too can ignore the DNC and schedule their primaries however and whenever they want, knowing full well that at the end of the day, the DNC rules have no teeth. Hopefully, the DNC will show some backbone on Saturday.
Friday, February 29, 2008
The Death and Re-Birth of Conservatism
Conservatism is dead, long live Conservatism.
In this day of highly polarized politics, no one philosophy has garnered more attention and acquired more influence than what is most commonly referred to as "right-wing extremism." Fueled in part by evangelical Christians 30-year conversion to the Republican party, and in part by talk radio hosts who appeal to the lowest common denominator (and by extension the least thoughtful/intelligent members of the electorate), this particular brand of social (as opposed to fiscal) conservatism has taken hold at every level of government, including most recently the White House.
The social conservative movement really hit its stride after September 11, providing a galvanizing call to arms in defense of a "new" and overt culture war. The American Christian Nation (ACN), the spearhead of Western European Christian Civilization, came into the light in order to defend against the Radical Fascist Islamic Fundamentalist movement that was sweeping the Middle East and the sub-Asian continent.
For years the ACN had been rallying against domestic moral failings - abortion, homosexuality, rock and rap music, and whatever else they didn't understand or like. They were (and are) intolerant, because tolerance equals acceptance, acceptance equals surrender, and surrender equals damnation. The issues were divisive and the ACN could do no more than preach to the choir - it was a total failure at converting the majority of Americans. 9-11 however gave them a cause that all Americans could get behind, or at least could not publically decry. And as a result, they believe they had crossed that last hurdle and had wrested control of America from the heathen majority.
Then came John McCain.
Conventional wisdom has long held that to win a party's nomination, a presidential candidate must carry the South, and in the case of Republicans, must carry the ACN (which is fairly headquartered in the South). In order to carry that vote, a Republican candidate must campaign on issues that make the ACN happy - anti-abortion, anti-homosexuality, God in the classroom, and lip service to tax/spending control.
McCain is not a member of the ACN, and is not a true believer in the ACN movement. Rather, he is a pragmatist who holds his own opinions and rejects extremism is any form. And while his beliefs may not line up with yours or mine or the guy down the street, he does a pretty good job of keeping the pandering to a minimum.
With his pending nomination as the Republican presidential nominee, the ACN is going through a series of spasmodic seizures, trying to figure out what happened and how their party's nominee doesn't share their values. In particular, the ACN radio-show talking heads, i.e. Limbaugh, Hannity, Beck, and the nameless ass-clown who got dissed by McCain earlier in the week, are all spitting mad that they have failed to sway the vote as they have in the past. (In fact, their vehement denials of such frustration only reinforces the fact of its presence - they doth protest too much).
It is pretty clear to anyone who has been paying attention for the past three years - America is fed up with the ACN and is about to re-assert its status as the majority. If Conservatism is not dead, it is at least Terri Schivo (or at least the ACN's opionion of Terri Schivo). A McCain victory in November would effectively pull the plug. Yes, McCain has campaigned on a platform of maintaining some elements of Bush's policies - that can hardly be a surprise. And yet it does not make him a Bush clone, as much as some might like to suggest. McCain is a moderate pragmatist - the antithesis of and an anathema to the ACN.
On the other hand, if McCain loses, the ACN will be able to rally and point out "see, without us the GOP cannot win." The result will be a shift in the GOP so far to the right that it might even rival the Oregon GOP. The ACN will gain not just control, but absolute control of the GOP for decades to come.
If you know anything about the Oregon GOP, you know that it is controlled by a cabal of ACN fanatics what have for decades proven incapable of winning a statewide general election for any office. Why? Because they field candidates who are true-blue ACN followers, while Oregon generally is about 160-degrees the opposite (the ACN does have some minor local traction throughout Oregon, but not much). The Oregon GOP would rather field candidates who will rigidly adhere to their ACN principles than candidates who can win. And if McCain loses, it is likely the national GOP will go the same route. Conservatism will thus be re-born, but will find itself flailing against the current for many years to come (or until the Democrats screw things up so badly that once again voters will chose change for the sake of change, consequences be damned).
McCain's nomination has dealt a near-fatal blow to Conservatism. His election will kill it entirely. His defeat will revive it and give rise to a Frankenstein's-monster version of the GOP.
Either way, it'll be a hell of a show.
In this day of highly polarized politics, no one philosophy has garnered more attention and acquired more influence than what is most commonly referred to as "right-wing extremism." Fueled in part by evangelical Christians 30-year conversion to the Republican party, and in part by talk radio hosts who appeal to the lowest common denominator (and by extension the least thoughtful/intelligent members of the electorate), this particular brand of social (as opposed to fiscal) conservatism has taken hold at every level of government, including most recently the White House.
The social conservative movement really hit its stride after September 11, providing a galvanizing call to arms in defense of a "new" and overt culture war. The American Christian Nation (ACN), the spearhead of Western European Christian Civilization, came into the light in order to defend against the Radical Fascist Islamic Fundamentalist movement that was sweeping the Middle East and the sub-Asian continent.
For years the ACN had been rallying against domestic moral failings - abortion, homosexuality, rock and rap music, and whatever else they didn't understand or like. They were (and are) intolerant, because tolerance equals acceptance, acceptance equals surrender, and surrender equals damnation. The issues were divisive and the ACN could do no more than preach to the choir - it was a total failure at converting the majority of Americans. 9-11 however gave them a cause that all Americans could get behind, or at least could not publically decry. And as a result, they believe they had crossed that last hurdle and had wrested control of America from the heathen majority.
Then came John McCain.
Conventional wisdom has long held that to win a party's nomination, a presidential candidate must carry the South, and in the case of Republicans, must carry the ACN (which is fairly headquartered in the South). In order to carry that vote, a Republican candidate must campaign on issues that make the ACN happy - anti-abortion, anti-homosexuality, God in the classroom, and lip service to tax/spending control.
McCain is not a member of the ACN, and is not a true believer in the ACN movement. Rather, he is a pragmatist who holds his own opinions and rejects extremism is any form. And while his beliefs may not line up with yours or mine or the guy down the street, he does a pretty good job of keeping the pandering to a minimum.
With his pending nomination as the Republican presidential nominee, the ACN is going through a series of spasmodic seizures, trying to figure out what happened and how their party's nominee doesn't share their values. In particular, the ACN radio-show talking heads, i.e. Limbaugh, Hannity, Beck, and the nameless ass-clown who got dissed by McCain earlier in the week, are all spitting mad that they have failed to sway the vote as they have in the past. (In fact, their vehement denials of such frustration only reinforces the fact of its presence - they doth protest too much).
It is pretty clear to anyone who has been paying attention for the past three years - America is fed up with the ACN and is about to re-assert its status as the majority. If Conservatism is not dead, it is at least Terri Schivo (or at least the ACN's opionion of Terri Schivo). A McCain victory in November would effectively pull the plug. Yes, McCain has campaigned on a platform of maintaining some elements of Bush's policies - that can hardly be a surprise. And yet it does not make him a Bush clone, as much as some might like to suggest. McCain is a moderate pragmatist - the antithesis of and an anathema to the ACN.
On the other hand, if McCain loses, the ACN will be able to rally and point out "see, without us the GOP cannot win." The result will be a shift in the GOP so far to the right that it might even rival the Oregon GOP. The ACN will gain not just control, but absolute control of the GOP for decades to come.
If you know anything about the Oregon GOP, you know that it is controlled by a cabal of ACN fanatics what have for decades proven incapable of winning a statewide general election for any office. Why? Because they field candidates who are true-blue ACN followers, while Oregon generally is about 160-degrees the opposite (the ACN does have some minor local traction throughout Oregon, but not much). The Oregon GOP would rather field candidates who will rigidly adhere to their ACN principles than candidates who can win. And if McCain loses, it is likely the national GOP will go the same route. Conservatism will thus be re-born, but will find itself flailing against the current for many years to come (or until the Democrats screw things up so badly that once again voters will chose change for the sake of change, consequences be damned).
McCain's nomination has dealt a near-fatal blow to Conservatism. His election will kill it entirely. His defeat will revive it and give rise to a Frankenstein's-monster version of the GOP.
Either way, it'll be a hell of a show.
Labels:
conservatism,
election,
GOP,
McCain,
oregon,
Republican
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

