Monday, August 27, 2007

Inconvenient civilian control of the military

It's hard to argue with people who have been maimed or lost family members in the war in Iraq.  Whether it's Cindy Sheehan who uses her son's death to seek an end to the war, or other's who use their loved-ones' deaths to justify continuing the war, attacking their arguments is always met with a "they earned the right to take position 'x', so leave them alone."


Someone (I forget who) once said "war is a continuation of politics by another means," or something like that.  I can see no valid reason why participating in one aspect of political action (e.g. war) gives one a greater insight into the policy underlying that extension of political thought than, say, me, or anybody in congress.


With that in mind ...


The other day I began seeing these commercials here in Tennessee (I assume they are elsewhere around the country).  (I won't slow your load time by embedding them here).  I won't get into the details of each ad and why any particular ad is mind-boggling in both its naivete and outright stupidity.  However, one consistent theme demands comment.


My daughter just turned 12.  While watching these ads, she hears these people say, using different wording, that politics, and by extension politicians, should not be deciding whether the war continues.  She looked over at me and said "but isn't that how it's SUPPOSED to work!?"


Now, she's 12, and she apparently understands the fundamental concept of civilian control of the military - namely that the military does what the civilians, through the politicians, say.  They don't go to war without political okay - and they come home when the politicians say so.  The military doesn't get to decide when and where it's going to fight.  The military is the tail - it is not the dog.


"Don't play politics" with the military is a resounding theme in these ads - and one that is precisely wrong in both its conceptual foundation and its pragmatic demand.  War is exactly that - a political game.  It's very function is to serve as a tool of politicians and as one extension of foreign policy.  And just as it is the right of the politicians to use that tool, it is no less their right to withdraw its use.


Freedom's Watch, the organization sponsoring these ads, is frightfully nearer the political philopsophies of Stalinists and Communists than freedom-loving Americans.  To even harbor, for a moment, the thought of relinquishing civilian control of the military (even as such philosphy is phrased in terms of "don't act") is the first, clear step toward dictatorship and a shift to the far-left side of the "J curve" (which I'll discuss in another post).


All freedom loving Americans should watch Freedom's Watch, and make damn sure they don't gain a foothold anywhere that matters.  "We have met the enemy, and he is us."

America - now 20% less filling!

So the other night I end up having to watch the Miss Teen USA pageant. I usually watch those shows just long enough to see the contestant from Oregon get the boot. Unfortunately, I now also have to wait to see what happens to the contestant from Tennessee, and damn if that girl didn't make the final 15.


So anyhow, it gets down to the final five and the contestants must draw a name of a judge from a fishbowl, and then answer the question that judge asks. Miss South Carolina is first.


Much as they did Miss South Carolina, words fail me here. You just have to watch (and listen) before reading any farther.



Something about the south and edumacation I guess. Whether it's Kansas adopting (at least for a while) intelligent design (see my previous post here, about half way down - go to August 10), or South Carolina's efforts at watering down education and replacing it with religious indocrination, I can only assume that the 20% of Americans who can't find the US on a map are that way because there are no maps of the US in the Bible.


You gotta feel sorry for this girl. She's been raised in a culture where her looks and physical abilities (apparently she's a star soccer player as well as a national model) have made it unecessary to also, you know, think.


Anyhow, the sponsors of the pageant (in particular Donald Trump) must have been cringing, seeing their efforts to portray these girls as bright, intelligent and the future leaders of tomorrow go South (literally and figuratively) - assuming they could find "south" on a map.

Tuesday, January 17, 2006

Sanctity of life?

Sometimes reality is funnier than any fiction.

In this story, an elderly California death-row inmate had requested prison officials let him die if he suffered another heart attack before his execution.

Sayeth the prison official:

"At no point are we not going to value the sanctity of life," said prison spokesman Vernell Crittendon. "We would resuscitate him," then execute him.

Only in America.

BTW, it took two lethal injections to finish this guy off, who had recently lost his petition for clemency arguing that he was too old and feeble to be executed.

Gonzalez v. Oregon - Oregon Wins!

Yeah for me. I called it (I guess). The U.S. Supreme Court today upheld the Oregon Death With Dignity Act (DWDA) in a 6-3 decision. Roberts, Thomas and Scalia dissented. (I called that, too).

Like I anticipated in my previous post on this topic on the day of oral argument, the majority distinguished this case from Gonzalez v. Raich, in which the Court rejected the state of California's argument in support of its medical marijuana law.

And although in my previous post I thought the Court might skirt the issue by simply saying the Attorney General has the authority to interpret his own rule (which is basically the dissent's position), the Court hit that subject head on and said the AG overstepped his authority.

It's an important decision because it, theoretically, removes at least overt politics from the office of the Attorney General, who is supposed to be above that.

Friday, January 13, 2006

Alito v. Roe? Not likely.

Much has been made of Supreme Court nominee Samuel Alito's refusal to state that Roe v. Wade is "settled law." As a result, many in the pro-choice camp are making as much noise as possible about Alito's confirmation to the Supreme Court being the likely death-knell for reproductive rights in this country. Clearly, they did not listen to the hearings.

Two very important things were said at the confirmation hearings that should give pause to those who belief Alito spells the end for Roe. First, Alito was unequivocal in his affirmation of the right to privacy being found in the Constitution. And second, Alito refused to back away from that position when pressed - hard - by right-wing nut job Sen. Thomas Coburn (R-Ok).

Anti-abortion activitists are vehement in their collective opinion that Roe v. Wade was wrongly decided. Specifically, they note that the Constitution does not contain a right to privacy. And, in the most literal sense, they are correct. There is, in fact, no express right to privacy anywhere in the U.S. Constitution.

However, the Supreme Court has found that the right to privacy is implied within the Fourth, Fifth, and Fourteenth Amendments. The far right repeatedly calls this "judicial activism." Justices like Antonin Scalia, a so-called "strict constructionist," would not find rights in the Constitution that are not expressly written into the document. It was widely believed that Alito shared Scalia's minimalist view of the Constitution and personal rights.

Thus, it was with almost jaw-dropping amazement that I listened to Alito clearly and unequivocally state the the Constitution did, in fact, contain a right to privacy, and that it was found at least in the Fourth, Fifth and Fifteenth Amendments. That was huge - huger than huge - perhaps earth-shattering. And it went virtually unnoticed, or certainly unappreciated.

At least, unnoticed to everyone except Tom Coburn, the right-wing crackpot from Okalahoma. Listening to Coburn proselytize from the dais caused me to grind my teeth - it was absolute agony listening to him whine and bitch and moan about his bizarre belief in the failing of the judiciary. However, he made a point to come at Alito and get him to admit that, although the Supreme Court has found a right to privacy, there is no such right actually in the document. Alito, quite properly, acknowledged the absence of the word "privacy" in the text of the Constitution, but then very forcefully reinforced his earlier statement that the Constitution does contain a right to privacy, even if not expressly stated. Eventually, Coburn gave up.

Finally, I note that Alito was entirely correct to refuse to acknowledge that Roe v. Wade is "settled law." Simply put, it is not. Brown v. Board of Education is settled law. Roe left open room for modification, and the Court has repeatedly said as much. Abortion rights are not yet settled in stone, and the degree to which government may regulate abortion and other reproductive issues remains an open question. Thus, Alito's refusal to commit to Roe as unalterable is legally, factually, and practically correct. It doesn't mean he opposes Roe - it means that Roe is open to collateral attack - and, like it or not, it is.

Alito may not be the best choice to replace outgoing Justice Sandra Day O'Connor. He might not even be a good choice. But it is unfair, and incorrect, to label him as the mortal enemy of reproductive rights, based on his refusal to adhere to a legally untenable position.

Thursday, January 05, 2006

American Idiots

Great article here in the November 2005 issue of Esquire, discussing why so many people, "Idiot America," are more likely to believe talking heads rather than experts - i.e. scientists who might actually know something.

PC NCAA FUBAR (update)

Great column here by George Will discussing the NCAA's silly hate-free mascot policy. (See my previous discussion here).

The column ended strong, and I quote it here for your convenience and entertainment:

But this is an age when being an offended busybody is considered evidence of advanced thinking and an exquisite sensibility. So, People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals has demanded that the University of South Carolina's teams not be called Gamecocks because cockfighting is cruel. It also is illegal in South Carolina. [See SC Code 16-17-650].

In 1972 the University of Massachusetts at Amherst replaced the nickname Redmen with Minutemen. White men carrying guns? If some advanced thinkers are made miserable by this, will the NCAA's censors offer relief? Scottsdale Community College in Arizona was wise to adopt the nickname "Fighting Artichokes." There is no grievance group representing the lacerated feelings of artichokes. Yet.

"Kerry Wins" shirts in Haiti?

Had a thought. Ever notice how when a sports team wins a championship, they suddenly have shirts and hats commemorating the win? Well, obviously they didn't just print those up in five minutes. Rather, there are shirts and hats printed for both sides.

Turns out that many times the clothing commemorating the losing team's non-victory is either destroyed or donated. Seems people in Haiti were running around with shirts last year commemorating the University of Oklahoma's football championship win over USC, who actually won the game.

So I wonder - are there a bunch of Hatians now running around in "Kerry Wins!" t-shirts?

Wednesday, January 04, 2006

My monkey-butt fetish revealed.

I thought I was alone in the world. But, alas, it seems I am not.

In a story discussing how monkeys perceive differences (i.e. small v. big; many v. few) like people, Fox News reports (and I've decided) that apparently we share even more in common with our simian relatives:

"This finding is the most recent in a series of discoveries that indicate our primate cousins display human-like characteristics. Monkeys like to gamble and enjoy looking at other monkeys' bottoms.'" (emphasis added).

The results were subsequently confirmed by Dr. Cornelius.

For more on monkey butts:

"Interest in porn a case of monkey see, monkey do," Milwaukee Journal Sentinal, March 5, 2005.

"Monkeys Pay to See Female Monkey Bottoms," Free Republic, January 28, 2005.

"Rhesus Pieces," The Washington Post, March 6, 2005. (If they ever make monkey porn, this HAS to be the title of the first movie).

The "War" on Christmas

Perhaps this could be more broadly titled "The 'War' on Christians." Anybody who happened to watch Fox News this past Christmas season certainly was exposed to the argument that there is some sort of "war" on Christmas, and specifically on the Christian theme of Christmas.

Leading the charge seemed to be Fox News pundit John Gibson, who authored a book titled "The War On Christmas: How the Liberal Plot to Ban the Sacred Christian Holiday is Worse Than You Thought." I haven't read the book. I have, however, listened to Gibson's radio show, in which he devoted hours, if not days, to this supposed "war."

Boiled down, however, is that the "War on Christmas" has two elements: First, there are the wacko school-boards, city councils, etc. who have, in fits of leftist apoloxy, have banned the Christian elements of Christmas. Some have banned the singing of traditional Christmas carols, such as Silent Night. In 2000, the city of Eugene, OR banned Christmas trees from city property.

Second, several "big box" retailers use the phrase "Happy Holidays" in their advertising. I'll deal with that last.

Notably, for every crackpot school or city manager who is scared by the threat of a lawsuit into taking stupid actions (all of which, by the way, end up being temporary - no permanent ban on carols or trees has ever occurred so far as I can ascertain - and I'm sure if there was the Christian right would have let us all know), there are several more false stories that the Right tries to use to fuel its argument.

For example, Fox News talking head Bill O'Reilly accused the Plano, TX school district of banning red and green clothing. Turns out, however, that it never happened. Likewise, the World Net Daily, a Christian-right website that is likewise sounding the alarm, accused the Glendale-Rivers School District in Glendale, WI of banning Christmas carols, but permitting Hanukkah songs because they are "cultural" rather than "religious." That story relied, exclusively, on a press-release from a Christian-right "law firm." Specifically, the school district is accused of keeping out religious-themed songs:

"The intent of the school district's policy is clear – 'Frosty the Snowman' is in, 'My Dreidel' is in, 'Silent Night' is out," said Mat Staver, Liberty Counsel president and general counsel.
However, that is, not surprisingly, not true. The first-grade class at Parkway Elementary School (which is in the Glendale-Rivers School District), sang "Angels We Have Heard on High," and everybody sang "Let There Be Peace on Earth."

It would be belief that, if there was a "war" on Christmas, somebody would tell me where I cannot say "Merry Christmas." If there was a "war" on Christmas, where are the battle lines? Where are the casualties? The occasional temporary misguided order from a school in a town I've never heard of is hardly a sign of "war." Rather, it is the exact opposite. The very nature of these debacles - i.e. temporary and occassional, indicate that, if there is a "war," it is going very poorly for whomever is waging it.

Instead, this is a fabricated battlefield with a less obvious but still clear agenda - there is a growing backlash against the Christian Right in this country. The past several years have seen a rapid rise in prominence of the Christian Right, as it did toward the end of the Regan-Bush era. However, the Clinton years saw the decline of that element in its ability to influence public policy on a broad and, specifically, federal level.

Today's leaders of the Christian Right have learned the lesson there - all glory is fleeting. Consequently, they have pushed harder than ever to create permanent inroads. However, like any cause that has taken center stage for too long, they have started to wear out their welcome. Just like people got tired of seeing the Chicago Bulls in the NBA finals year after freakin' year, now they are tired of seeing these bible-thumping megalomanics bastardize the Christian faith for their own grab at power.

As a result, there is a growing backlash, and a growing sentiment that enough is enough. This is not anti Christian - it is merely an attempt to return the country to a "status quo" where Christianity has a smaller, but still visible, place in the public-policy arena. The Christian Right has realized this, however, and thus fabricated the "War on Christmas" in order to rally the troops and keep hold of the territory they've gained in the past five or six years. That, of course, would also explain the reliance on rumor and falsehoods. There is no real "war" of any consequence actually taking place, so one has to be made up.

Finally, the retailer issue. I was unaware that the Christian element of Christmas relied on Wal-Mart and Target to convey the message. I thought that's what church was for. Silly me. But seriously, I am pretty certain that those stores (1) cater to non-Christians, and (2) want shoppers to come in and shop from Thanksgiving to post-New Year - i.e. the Holiday Season.

Merry Christmas and Happy New Year - belated.


Wednesday, November 30, 2005

Would life on Mars mean there is no God?

Wow - it's been a month since I've last posted anything. Where have I been?

Anyway, I was reading this story (click above) about the ongoing search for life on Mars, and I got to thinking - if life on Mars in some form once existed, but couldn't get off the ground (as it were), would that mean there is no God?

For starters, God is infallible - yet His attempt to spark life on Mars failed. If God's only role is to direct the evolution of higher order, then He still hasn't "created" anything - He's merely retooled an existing product. Because God knows all (since He exists in all times simultaneously), why would He bother with something He knew wouldn't work?

I have not seen this issue raised anywhere yet - nobody seems to consider the ramifications of finding life elsewhere in the solar system. Personally, I'd like to see the "intelligent design" crowd explain that one.

Thursday, October 27, 2005

Alberto Gonzales for SCOTUS

Just a quick note here: I want Alberto Gonzales to be the next supreme court nominee. Why? Because he is the author or advocate of so many significant decisions that will come before the Court. Consequently, he will have to recuse himself. Since many of those decisions/positions are being rejected by the lower courts, it is likely that his recusal will result in 4-4 splits that necessarily result in affirmation of the lower court's ruling.

Specifically, I want the Court to uphold Oregon's Death with Dignity Act. Right now, Oregon probably wins that case at least 5-4 (and maybe 6-3), with O'Conner on the winning side. Many seem to think that if she is replaced and the result is then 4-4, the new justice will make it 5-4 for overturning the law. However, Gonzales, as AG whose office argued against the law before the Court, would have to recuse himself, leaving the vote, at worst, at 4-4, and thus affirming the Ninth Circuit's decision to uphold the law.

GO AL!!

Wednesday, October 26, 2005

Early entry into pro sports

First my disclaimer: I hate professional sports. All of them.

I haven't always. It's a recent thing. I used to hate college sports. Thought they were stupid, low-talent, etc. Now I realize that college sports (in any flavor) are better than professional sports.

Why? One reason - heart.

College kids just play harder. Most of them play for the fun of the game. A few play for the shot at being drafted and becoming millionaires. In either case, they have more incentive.

I realized this many years ago (but didn't make the connection) when I attended Portland Winter Hawks games. If you don't know, the Winter Hawks are Portland's minor league (AAA equivalent) hockey team. Those guys play (and fight) hard because they have to prove their worth to get to the NHL (back when the NHL existed).

Pro athletes have the contracts, endorsements, etc. before they ever put on a uniform. Before they've ever done a damn thing. Why should they play hard then? They're gonna get paid whether they ball or not. Worst that can happen is that they get traded or benched - but they still get paid.

One of my greatest peeves with pro sports though (and the real reason I hate them) is the decreasing quality of the pro game (namely basketball and, to a lesser extent, football). Allowing kids to come in with minimal or no college time is assinine. These kids were superstars in high school, which means they were rewarded for basically taking over a game - i.e. playing selfish.

College ball is full of kids who were also high school superstars (or stars), so you can't really just run over people like you used to in high school. Thus, players have to learn to adjust their game to the team concept while enhancing fundamentals that must change to the evolved skill level of the competition (i.e., your high school jump shot won't cut it in the face of an NBA defender).

I have never understood why the pro leagues don't simply require college degrees. Yeah, so some dumb-asses won't make it. So what? Isn't that consistent after all with the hypocritical "stay-in-school" v. skip college messages sent by the pro leagues?

I guess the NFL's new rule comes closest so far - requiring a draftee's high school class to have finished college. In other words, you can sit out four years, or play college football for four years (three plus a redshirt I guess). I imagine most would play, and the rule lets them leave after their junior season (if they redshirted). Basketball could do this too.

In the meantime, we'll continue to have dressed-up high school basketball presented as the professional game, and we'll have NFL draftees who take 4 years to learn the game, and it'll all just continue to suck.

I hate pro sports.

Wednesday, October 12, 2005

I'm going to die.

For those regular readers (all two of you) I want you to know that it has been a pleasure entertaining you. However, it turns that I will be dying on Saturday, March 30, 2041. I know this may come as a shock to many of you, but so it goes. One does not argue with the Death Clock.

Apparently, I could extend my time here until Thursday, April 29, 2060 if I became an optimist.

Screw that.

I only wonder if I'll finally get to meet the Flying Spaghetti Monster, face-to-noodly-face. Guess I'll have to ask my Magic 8 Ball.

Monday, October 10, 2005

Ann Coulter Partially Sane!

Click here for an article that notes how even Ann Coulter had a lucid moment (two in fact!) when she came out critical of Meiers' nomination.

Meirs linked to corporate scandal?

Hmmm. Seems that while Supreme Court nominee Harriet Meiers was managing partner at the Texas law firm of Locke Purnell Rain Harrell, they got hit with $30 million in fines for vouching for the reputations of some Ponzi scheme crooks, which vouching induced some fools to soonly part with their money. (Click on the title of this post to view the complete article).

For my part, that's a nail in the coffin. There are very few people from whom I demand the highest character - but I think it's fair that in a country of nearly 400 million, I can demand that nine of those people be, essentially, without flaw.

Is that asking too much?

George Will on Harriet Meirs (figuratively, of course)

Good ol' George Will has taken Bush to task on his selection of Harriet Meiers to the U.S. Supreme Court. In his column (click on the title of this post to read the column) he sets out three "starting points" for the Senate to keep in mind as it looks forward to the confirmation hearings:

"First, it is not important that she be confirmed. Second, it might be very important that she not be. Third, the presumption -- perhaps rebuttable but certainly in need of rebutting -- should be that her nomination is not a defensible exercise of presidential discretion to which senatorial deference is due."


Better yet, he all but calls W too dumb to be permitted to make decisions that might involve the Constitution, when he says:

"The president's "argument" for her amounts to: Trust me. There is no reason to, for several reasons.

"He has neither the inclination nor the ability to make sophisticated judgments about competing approaches to construing the Constitution. Few presidents acquire such abilities in the course of their pre-presidential careers, and this president particularly is not disposed to such reflections."

That's the nicest way I have ever heard anybody call anybody else "dumb."

As for Meirs herself, Will suggests that:

"If 100 such people had been asked to list 100 individuals who have given evidence of the reflectiveness and excellence requisite in a justice, Miers's name probably would not have appeared in any of the 10,000 places on those lists."

I can understand appointing someone with no judicial experience to the Supreme Court, if that person had some body of work (courtroom or academic) that reflected a solid and in-depth understanding of the Constitution and constitutional law. Meiers has no such experience and no relevant body of work upon which the Senate (or the people) can make an informed decision. She was a corporate lawyer at the Texas law firm of Locke, Liddell & Sapp (note that many "corporate" lawyers have never seen the inside of a courtroom), on some city council, president of the Texas Bar Association, and is nice. Yippee.

But I have to agree with Will here - there are at least 10,000 more-qualified candidates than this woman. There are certainly many, many more qualified conservative candidates.

Speaking of which, this strikes me as kinda funny. W has insisted that he would appoint candidates who share the judicial philosophy of Justice Antonin Scalia. Now, as far as I can tell, the only other human being who intentionally chooses to think like Scalia is William F. Buckley (Justice Clarence Thomas doesn't count - at least not until he demonstrates an ability to think for himself rather than be Scalia's lap dog). So far, nobody Bush has appointed is like Scalia - not even a little bit. Thus, this raises an obvious question that I have never heard asked: Does George Bush know who Antonin Scalia is? Has Bush ever actually read a Supreme Court opinion, much less one of Scalia's "the other judges on this Court are stupid assholes" dissents?





Friday, October 07, 2005

Refineries - about damn time.

Finally, the gov't is doing something about increasing our refinery capacity. People can bitch and moan about reducing our dependence on foreign oil 'till their blue in the face for all I care. Foreign oil is where it's at for the short and medium term (i.e. next 100 years).

It's a little known secret that the reason the cost of gas is so high at the pump is because of the bottleneck at the refineries. Increasing the number of refineries will lower the price of gas for consumers - obviously not overnight, and probably not for a good 3-5 years.

This Slate article does a good job summarizing why the real villians in the rise of gas prices are the refiners, not OPEC and not the local gas station. Why are more refineries good? Current refineries are running at 94 percent capacity, and have no domestic competition. The largest independent refiner, Valero, saw its stock rise 226 percent in the past year. Here's another good article on the need for greater refinery capacity. Capitalism requires competition in order to hold down prices and not drive the economy downward.

There are those who contend otherwise, and argue that building more refineries is sacrificing the environment to the benefit of oil companies. Maybe - but only a little bit. I'm willing to accept some environmental sacrifice from time-to-time, so long as it's reasonable and necessary. This is. Will oil companies make more money? Maybe, but I'm okay with that. I would rather see them make money on volume rather than margin, because at least I know I'm not getting screwed in the process. If they get richer - good for them. Wish I was one of 'em.

More evidence that Rumsfeld should be in prison

This is a great blog by William Arkin, military analyst for the Washington Post.

In it, he refers to a memo written by Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld asking "Are we winning or losing the Global War on Terror?" The memo is dated October 16, 2003, more than two years after 9/11 and the October 7, 2001 initiation of the "War on Terror." Two years into it, and the head guy doesn't know if he's winning or losing? I'm sorry, but to me, the answer is very simple, if you are not winning, you are losing - and if you are winning, you know it. Ergo, the question is itself an acknowledgment that we are losing (because, yes, in this case, an indeterminate outcome equates to a loss).

One of Rumsfeld's more interesting observations is our lack of metrics to ascertain our progress. In other words, we do not have a measuring stick. This is interesting and important because it directly addresses a point raised by Michael Scheuer in his book "Imperial Hubris: Why the West is Losing the War on Terror" By way of set up, Scheuer led the CIA's bin Laden unit until 1999, and published his book as "Anonymous" due to CIA regulations. The book itself is an "open source" text (thereby saving it from being stamped "secret" and shelved) and started out as an unclassified training manual for new counterterrorism operatives working on bin Laden and Sunni extremism. (See link here).

In any event, Scheuer notes that it is impossible to determine whether our capture and/or killing of various high-profile targets has made a dent. This is because we do not have an "order-of-battle" study in place for al Qaeda. (Imperial Hubris, p.67). He says, "[w]ithout this basic reference point it is impossible to objectively determine how badly or permanently al Qaeda has been damaged." (Id). Without going into detail, he notes that we simply have no way of knowing whether we are successful.

So back to Rumsfeld. Now, two years after asking the question, the DOD has finally decided to start the process of seeking an answer. On September 8, 2005, the DOD sent out a solicitation for bids on a contract to develop "a system of metrics to accurately assess US progress in the War on Terrorism, identify critical issues hindering progress and develop, and track action plans to resolve the issues identified."

In other words, four years into the "War on Terror," and the DOD finally decides that it should maybe develop a method of evaluating its progress. Seriously, can ANYBODY whose head is not completely up their ass believe that BushCo have the first clue about what they're doing? I mean, aside from the lack of sufficient forces on the ground, the faulty intelligence, the total failure to grasp Middle Eastern and Islamic culture, and the stubborn refusal to actually engage in a real war on terror, now this? Four years into the game, and we're just now contracting to define the rules and build the scoreboard!?

One of the problems the DOD now faces is that any system it develops for measuring success/defeat will be based on a military perspective, which is incongruent with the law-enforcement mindset that dominates this alleged "War on Terror." Our policy is not to defeat terrorists through their military destruction, it is to arrest them. Occassionally, more by dumb luck than design, we manage to kill some. Scheuer argues in his conclusion that we must stop viewing bin Laden as a terrorist, because he is not. He says, "Al Qaueda attacks are terrifying, but acts of war are like that. Bin Laden is leading and inspiring a worldwide anti-U.S. insurgency; he is waging war while we fight him with counterterrorism policies dominated by law-enforcement tactics and procedures. It has not and will not work." (Imperial Hubris, p. 246) (emphasis added).

Scheuer goes on to note that, "[a]s practiced by the United States, counterterrorism is appeasment; it lets the enemy attack and survive, keeps allies sweet by staying the hand of the U.S. military forces they hate, and ignores the true terrorist states in the Sunni Persian Gulf because they own much of the world's oil. The bloated, risk-averse, and lawyer-palsied (counterterrorism) community ensured state sponsors and their proxies survived, and now it blocks the counterinsurgency strategy needed to beat al Qaeda." (Id. at 246-47).

It will be interesting to see if the DOD assessment ultimate results in a revised methodolgy that mirrors one of the issues raised in Scheuer's book. Since the days of Grant and Lee (and the Overland Campaign), the U.S. military has trained its officers to wage war with a blood-letting mindset. Massive destruction, massive casualties, unrelenting pace. Today, war is fought for the television cameras, so we get nifty pictures of laser-guided bombs. However, as Scheuer notes, "[d]ainty U.S. military attacks convince our Muslim friends and foes that America lacks the military savagery to either portect its allies or destroy its enemies, and that, despite massive U.S. military power, the Islamists can absorb U.S. attacks and fight again." Another author cited by Scheuer said, "[w]arriors will interpret such an aversion to violence as a wekness, emboldening their cause. ... For such adversaries, our moral values - our fear of colalteral damage- reperesnt our worst vulnerabilities." (Id. at 235, and quoting Robert D. Kaplan, Warrior Politics).

In short, either wage total, unrelenting and catastrophic war on the muslim world (I didn't get into Scheuer's point that this is not a war against extremists, but against the entire Muslim world), or agree to their demands, which are, simply, get out of the Gulf. (I also did not spend time discussing his point that bin Laden, et al, do not hate us for out values, politics, or way of life - they simply want the infidels out of their holy territory). Given the two options, only the first is viable and stands any likelihood of success - like it or not.

Why did 9/11 happen?

Recent discussions elsewhere have led to pause and back WAY up.

Now, I am curious, why do people believe Al Qaeda, and specifically Osama Bin Laden, attacked the United States? And if you have an opinion, from where does it originate? Can you link to a source? (preferrably as high as a secondary source - obviously nobody here (I hope) has direct access to OBL).

I'll wait patiently.